Maplevisa

PGP Application Return Challenge Dismissed

A Federal Court judge dismissed a challenge to a PGP application return after finding that the incomplete 2024 Parents and Grandparents Program sponsorship application had been returned for processing rather than refused. The Court held that the return was not a reviewable or justiciable decision.

A male judge in a black robe sits at a wooden desk covered with large stacks of paperwork, intently reading a document in a law library with bookshelves in the background.

Case Summary

  • Case & citation: Dang v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1402, Court file IMM-8715-25.
  • Decision date & judge: November 13, 2026, by the Honourable Madam Justice Ekaterina Tsimberis.
  • Issue: The applicant challenged IRCC’s return of a 2024 Parents and Grandparents Program sponsorship application as incomplete.
  • Outcome: The application for judicial review was dismissed because there was no reviewable or justiciable decision.

PGP application return followed incomplete history records

Himani Dang, a Canadian citizen, applied to sponsor her parents for permanent residence through the 2024 Parents and Grandparents Program(PGP). IRCC initially advised that the submission lacked valid passports, relationship evidence and complete documents, including the principal applicant’s Background/Declaration Form (IMM-5669) and resume.

IRCC gave Ms. Dang 30 days to provide the requested material. Before that deadline, she submitted passports, relationship evidence, a new resume and an amended IMM-5669 form.

In its April 7, 2025 letter, IRCC returned the sponsorship application because it found continuing gaps in the principal applicant’s personal, address and employment history. The letter also said another invitation to apply for the 2024 PGP would not be issued.

The parties’ submissions

Ms. Dang argued that the officer breached procedural fairness by not giving her another opportunity to correct the application. She also submitted that the decision was unreasonable because the officer did not grapple with the documents she provided in March 2025.

The Minister argued that the returned application was not a refusal of the sponsorship application and was therefore not a reviewable decision. The Minister also submitted that the officer was not required to offer a second opportunity to complete the submission.

Why the Court found no reviewable decision

Justice Tsimberis found that the amended IMM-5669 form and resume remained incomplete. The Court noted that the applicable Parents and Grandparents document checklist required the principal applicant to account for all periods of work and personal history; because she had been retired for more than 10 years, this included personal and work information from age 18 onward (para. 9).

The Court relied on subsection 87.3(5) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, which states that an application being retained, returned or otherwise disposed of does not amount to a decision not to issue the requested visa or status. It also cited section 12 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations, under which an application that does not meet the requirements in sections 10 and 11 must be returned (paras. 11–13).

On the record before it, the Court concluded that the incomplete PGP application had been returned rather than refused. That conclusion was determinative, so the Court did not address Ms. Dang’s procedural fairness and reasonableness arguments (para. 15).

The Court acknowledged that Ms. Dang would not receive another invitation to apply under the 2024 PGP, but said that consequence did not change the character of the refusal to process the incomplete application. The Court noted that the IRCC letter referred to the possibility that her parents and grandparents could be eligible for a super visa (para. 16).

Practical Implications for Lawyers and RCICs

The Court’s finding turned on both the incomplete corrected documents and the legal distinction between returning an application for non-compliance and refusing an application. For a comparable record, this suggests that the reviewability question may depend closely on whether the application was actually complete and on the procedural history of the return.

The Court also recorded the Minister’s concession that a request for reconsideration accompanied by a completed application, or a return of an application that was in fact complete, might not be categorically immune from judicial review (para. 14). This was not necessary to the dismissal and was not a general ruling on reconsideration requests.

Source: Federal Court Decisions

Disclaimer

Maplevisa provides Canadian immigration news and information for general informational purposes only. Content is not legal or immigration advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice based on your individual circumstances. Immigration laws, policies, programs, and procedures may change. Where applicable, readers should consult the relevant official government or legal source for current information.