Maplevisa
Humanitarian and Compassionate

Hardship and Country Conditions in H&C Cases

Learn how to present individualized hardship and country evidence in an H&C application without confusing humanitarian consideration with refugee protection.

1. Assessing Hardship

Hardship can be relevant to humanitarian and compassionate consideration, but section 25(1) does not establish a rigid checklist requiring a particular category of suffering in every case.

In Kanthasamy, the Supreme Court cautioned against treating the older phrase “unusual and undeserved or disproportionate hardship” as an inflexible legal threshold.

The analysis should identify the applicant’s actual circumstances and explain how the consequences of refusal interact with establishment, family relationships, children’s interests, health and other evidence. Generic assertions about hardship are less persuasive than a supported account of foreseeable effects.

LISTEN
Listen to this article
Ready to play

2. H&C Versus Refugee Protection

IRPA section 25(1.3) directs that an H&C officer may not consider the factors used to determine whether someone is a Convention refugee under section 96 or a person in need of protection under section 97(1), while requiring consideration of elements related to hardship affecting the applicant.

This is a substantive legal distinction, not a rule that all country evidence is irrelevant.

A submission should not ask the H&C officer to reverse a refugee-risk finding by another name. Instead, explain humanitarian consequences such as family separation, inability to maintain essential caregiving or practical barriers to health and education. The refugee guide addresses the separate protection regime.

3. Individualized Country Evidence

Reliable country reports can establish context about healthcare, education, discrimination, housing or social support. But a report describing national conditions does not establish how the applicant personally would be affected.

Connect each source to specific facts: a prescribed treatment, a child’s language needs, the absence of a caregiver, or a concrete financial barrier.

Where feasible, address regional differences and realistic alternatives. A broad claim that “services are unavailable” may be undermined by evidence of services in another region unless the applicant explains why they are inaccessible in practice.

4. Medical Care Abroad

Health evidence should identify the condition, functional limitations, required treatment, expected continuity of care and the realistic availability and affordability of that care after departure.

The physician’s role is to establish clinical facts; country evidence should address the service environment. A medical diagnosis alone does not establish the full humanitarian case.

Do not confuse the general hardship assessment with the narrower medical exception to the 12-month refugee bar, which has its own statutory requirements involving risk to life caused by inadequate medical care. See H&C restrictions.

5. Family Separation

Separation can be consequential where an applicant provides essential childcare, care for an ill relative or financial support that cannot readily be replaced.

Document the relationship, actual support and alternatives. The hardship analysis should consider both the person who may leave and those whose circumstances would materially change.

Where children are directly affected, their interests must be examined separately and with meaningful attention. See the BIOC guide.

6. Realistic Outcomes

A credible assessment compares plausible consequences of refusal: departure alone, family relocation, temporary separation or another feasible arrangement.

Explain legal custody restrictions, medical continuity, employment prospects and available family support as applicable. Do not assert that every conceivable adverse consequence is inevitable.

The objective is not to prove that life in Canada is preferable. It is to show why the combined circumstances justify the particular exemption sought, with evidence and a balanced account of alternatives.

7. Evidence Matrix

SourceWhat it can establishWhat still needs proof
Government country reportGeneral conditionsApplicant-specific exposure or impact
Clinical treatment planMedical needsActual access to equivalent care abroad
School or specialist recordsChild’s present needsLikely effects of relocation
Family support recordsExisting dependencyWhether reasonable alternatives exist

Use current, attributed sources and explain the significance of each. See the evidence and documents guide for exhibit organization.

8. Continue reading

Continue with a specialized guide:

Official information

Read the current IRCC application instructions and IRPA section 25 before relying on requirements or deadlines. This guide provides general information and is not individual legal advice.

View IRCC H&C application instructions