Best Interests of the Child in H&C Applications
Understand the legal duty to assess children directly affected by an H&C decision, including family separation, schooling, health, caregiving and supporting evidence.
1. Legal Duty
IRPA section 25(1) requires decision-makers to take into account the best interests of a child directly affected by an H&C decision.
This is not a discretionary courtesy: the child’s interests must receive genuine, individualized attention within the overall humanitarian assessment. It does not follow that the child’s interests automatically outweigh every other consideration or guarantee an exemption.
The applicant should identify each directly affected child, describe the child’s circumstances and provide evidence of foreseeable consequences. An assertion that “the children will suffer” is not a substitute for showing what would happen to particular children in realistic scenarios.
2. Baker and Kanthasamy
In Baker v Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), [1999] 2 SCR 817, the Supreme Court emphasized that children’s interests must be given serious attention in H&C decision-making.
In Kanthasamy v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 SCC 61, the Court explained that those interests must be identified, defined and examined with a high degree of attention in light of the evidence.
Neither judgment creates an automatic right to permanent residence for a parent of a Canadian child. The proper inquiry is child-specific and fact-sensitive, not a formula based on citizenship, school attendance or the existence of hardship in the abstract.
3. Affected Children
A child need not necessarily be a Canadian citizen or physically in Canada to be directly affected. Children may be affected through separation from a parent or caregiver, relocation, changes in financial support or disruption of an important relationship.
Identify the child’s age, residence, family and caregiving arrangements and the actual connection to the applicant.
Do not assume that every child named in a family tree is directly affected to the same degree. Explain the causal connection between the immigration decision and each child’s circumstances. Where there are siblings with different ages or needs, their interests should not be collapsed into one generic paragraph.
4. Separation and Relocation
Two scenarios often require distinct examination: the applicant leaves Canada while the child stays, and the child accompanies the applicant abroad.
The first may involve loss of daily care, financial support or emotional stability; the second may involve interrupted schooling, medical care, language difficulties or legal custody constraints. Sometimes neither scenario is straightforward, and evidence should explain why.
Where a custody order or shared-parenting arrangement exists, review the actual legal and practical limits on travel. Do not assume a child can relocate merely because the applicant proposes it. Conversely, do not assert that separation is inevitable without examining realistic alternatives.
5. Education and Health
Relevant evidence may include attendance records, individualized education plans, teacher observations, medical reports, therapy schedules and assessments of disability-related needs.
Explain the services currently received and what comparable services would realistically be accessible in the proposed destination. General statements that schools or hospitals are “worse abroad” rarely establish an individualized impact.
Where a child is very young, caregiving and developmental stability may be central. For an older child, education, social networks, language, identity and the child’s own views may require particular attention. The assessment should reflect the child’s age and maturity.
6. Children’s Views
Where appropriate, a child’s views can be presented in an age-sensitive and non-coercive manner. A child should not be asked to carry responsibility for the family’s immigration outcome.
Teachers, counsellors, physicians and other professionals may offer useful firsthand observations, but their records should be read within their expertise and not exaggerated into legal conclusions.
Protect sensitive information. An evidence package should contain enough detail for meaningful assessment while avoiding unnecessary exposure of a child’s medical, psychological or school records.
7. BIOC Evidence Matrix
| Issue | Evidence | Question for the submission |
|---|---|---|
| Caregiving | Schedules, household records, caregiver letters | Who provides essential daily support? |
| Schooling | Reports, learning plans, destination research | What educational change is foreseeable? |
| Health | Treatment plans and provider records | How would care continue or be disrupted? |
| Separation | Custody orders, contact and dependency evidence | What happens if the applicant leaves alone? |
For each child, identify the favourable and adverse aspects of each realistic outcome. This makes the assessment more credible than a one-sided assertion that any departure would necessarily be catastrophic.
8. Common Errors
Weak submissions rely on the child’s citizenship alone, reproduce generic country reports, ignore a non-applicant parent’s role, or discuss only one relocation scenario. Another error is to treat BIOC as a separate immigration entitlement rather than an important consideration within the section 25(1) discretion.
For a complete application, integrate the child-specific analysis with the supporting evidence, country conditions and the overall H&C legal framework.
An officer must meaningfully consider the child’s interests, but the applicant remains responsible for providing the relevant facts.
9. Continue reading
Continue with a specialized guide:
Read the current IRCC application instructions and IRPA section 25 before relying on requirements or deadlines. This guide provides general information and is not individual legal advice.
View IRCC H&C application instructions