Maplevisa

LMIA Work Permit Bank Statement Evidence: New Review Ordered

The Federal Court granted judicial review of an LMIA work permit bank statement evidence refusal and returned the application for redetermination by a different officer. The Court found that the officer did not address submitted payslips and Indian income tax returns when treating missing bank statements as essential.

A wooden desk with multiple stacks of paperwork, some sheets containing printed tables, and several notebooks with light blue covers arranged neatly.

Case Summary

  • Case & citation: Pal v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1436; Court file IMM-7184-25.
  • Decision date & judge: November 20, 2026, by Madam Justice Go.
  • Issue: An IRCC officer refused a work permit application based on a positive Labour Market Impact Assessment after finding the applicant had not provided bank statements.
  • Outcome: The judicial review was granted and the matter was returned to a different officer for redetermination.

Why the LMIA Work Permit Bank Statement Evidence Fell Short

The applicant, an Indian citizen, was applying for a three-year full-time position as an Ethnic Food Cook at an Ontario Indian grocery store. This was his third work permit application based on a positive LMIA.

He provided letters from employers, payslips from his current work as a samosa maker, and Indian income tax returns from 2018 to 2023. The officer refused the application after noting that no bank statements had been submitted and was not satisfied that he would leave Canada at the end of his authorized stay.

Justice Go applied the reasonableness standard. The Court found that the officer’s reasons did not mention the payslips or income tax returns, or explain why those documents did not address concerns about the source of the applicant’s funds and employment remuneration.

Court finds contradictory findings on employment

The Court also found the officer’s reasoning internally contradictory. The officer appeared to question whether the applicant’s employment in India was verified, while also referring to income that he derived from that employment when assessing his economic ties to India.

Justice Go held that the contradictory findings made the reasons unintelligible and unjustified. The Court did not decide whether the submitted documents were sufficient to establish the applicant’s financial establishment in India; that assessment is to be made again by a different officer.

Visa Office Instructions considered

The respondent noted that the New Delhi Visa Office Instructions required bank statements as proof of work experience and personal funds, and stated that failing to provide all required documents could result in refusal. However, the Court noted that the same instructions identified income tax returns as acceptable proof of personal funds and listed salary slips and employer letters as proof of work experience.

Justice Go observed that the work permit regulations at issue did not mention a proof-of-funds requirement. The Court further noted that the relevant Visa Office Instructions were non-binding, as conceded by the respondent.

Relying on the reasoning in Mohammad and Wasal, the Court concluded that the officer still had to consider the evidence that was submitted. In this case, the officer called the missing bank statements essential without explaining why or linking that conclusion to the Visa Office Instructions.

Practical Implications for Lawyers and RCICs

The Court’s finding was tied to the officer’s failure to engage with payslips and income tax returns that were already in the record, as well as the unexplained treatment of bank statements as essential (paras 11, 17–19). For a comparable work permit record, this suggests that a refusal based on absent financial documents may be vulnerable where the reasons do not meaningfully address alternative evidence submitted on employment, remuneration or personal funds.

The decision does not determine that payslips or income tax returns will always be sufficient, nor does it grant the work permit. It requires a new decision by a different officer.

Source: Federal Court Decisions

Disclaimer

Maplevisa provides Canadian immigration news and information for general informational purposes only. Content is not legal or immigration advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice based on your individual circumstances. Immigration laws, policies, programs, and procedures may change. Where applicable, readers should consult the relevant official government or legal source for current information.