An IAD appeal reopening application has been sent to a different Immigration Appeal Division panel for redetermination after the Federal Court found the division’s refusal unreasonable. The Court held that counsel’s admitted failure to file supporting documents denied Fariba Mottaghian Dini the opportunity to have her residency-obligation appeal heard.

Case Summary
- Case & citation: Dini v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1409, Court file IMM-16418-25.
- Decision date & judge: November 16, 2026, by the Honourable Madam Justice Kane.
- Issue: The Court reviewed the IAD’s refusal to reopen an appeal from the refusal of a Permanent Resident Travel Document application.
- Outcome: Judicial review was allowed, and the reopening application was remitted to a different IAD panel for redetermination.
Why the IAD appeal reopening refusal was unreasonable
Ms. Dini’s Permanent Resident Travel Document application was refused on July 29, 2024, because she did not meet the residency obligation. She appealed to the IAD, which set a March 10, 2025 deadline for her supporting documents.
The Court noted that Ms. Dini said she sent the documents to her counsel on February 13, 2025. A paralegal also attested that counsel had received the documents and prepared them for filing, but missed the deadline through an inadvertent oversight. The IAD declared the appeal abandoned on March 26, 2025.
When Ms. Dini applied to reopen the appeal, the IAD concluded that counsel’s inadvertent error did not establish a failure to observe natural justice. It distinguished her circumstances from an allegation of counsel incompetence and emphasized that she and counsel had received the deadline notice.
Justice Kane found that approach unreasonable. The Court held that the IAD focused on the label applied to counsel’s conduct rather than its consequence: Ms. Dini lost the opportunity to pursue her appeal because documents she had provided to counsel were not filed. The Court found this amounted to a failure to observe natural justice in the particular circumstances (paras 38, 41, 47).
Court distinguishes missed deadline cases
The Court said the IAD’s narrow reading of Shirwa was flawed. Although Ms. Dini had not specifically alleged counsel incompetence, the Court found that the omission could be characterized as error, negligence or incompetence, and that the central question was whether it denied her a hearing (paras 43, 45–47).
The Court also distinguished authorities relied on by the respondent. In particular, it noted that other cases involved technical errors, strategic decisions, an applicant’s own failure to attend, or evidence that was inconsistent or unconvincing. Here, the evidence explaining the missed filing deadline was detailed and unchallenged (paras 50–57).
Justice Kane did not treat missed deadlines as inconsequential. The reasons state that the Court does not condone them and does not absolve applicants or counsel of their obligation to comply with applicable rules and timelines. The finding that the IAD’s decision was unreasonable was expressly confined to Ms. Dini’s particular facts (para 58).
Practical Implications for Lawyers and RCICs
The Court’s material finding was that the IAD should have assessed the practical effect of counsel’s admitted omission, rather than treating the absence of a formal incompetence allegation as determinative (paras 41, 47–58).
For a comparable record, this suggests that a reopening request may need to clearly show how a documented counsel error directly prevented an applicant from receiving a hearing. The decision remains fact-specific and does not remove the onus on applicants and representatives to follow filing rules and deadlines.
Source: Federal Court Decisions
Maplevisa provides Canadian immigration news and information for general informational purposes only. Content is not legal or immigration advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice based on your individual circumstances. Immigration laws, policies, programs, and procedures may change. Where applicable, readers should consult the relevant official government or legal source for current information.