Maplevisa

Study Permit Refusal Over Financial Evidence Challenge Dismissed

The Federal Court has upheld a study permit refusal over financial evidence after finding that the applicant did not show the visa officer’s March 2025 decision was unreasonable. The Court dismissed the judicial review without costs.

Female judge in a black robe seated at a large wooden desk, focused on reading a document amid stacks of legal files and papers in a law library.

Case Summary

  • Case & citation: Ahadji v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 CF 1404, Court file IMM-6008-25.
  • Decision date & judge: November 16, 2026, Justice Benoit M. Duchesne.
  • Issue: The applicant challenged the refusal of her study permit application, including the officer’s assessment of access to financial support.
  • Outcome: The judicial review was dismissed without costs; the Court did not set aside the study permit refusal.

Why the study permit refusal over financial evidence was upheld

The applicant, a Togolese citizen, had been accepted to an 18-month medical-secretary program at Collège Supérieur de Sherbrooke. The Court said the program’s tuition, books, supplies, admission and registration costs totalled $21,516.

Her first study permit refusal, issued in August 2024, was set aside by consent after an earlier judicial-review proceeding. Her application was then reassessed by a different IRCC officer after she was allowed to submit additional or updated material.

For the redetermination, the applicant submitted an attestation concerning her father’s account at a mutual savings and credit institution, an update to her application and a third letter of admission. The March 17, 2025 refusal found that she had not established that her assets and financial situation would support the purpose of her trip and satisfy the officer that she would leave Canada at the end of her authorized stay.

The Court applied the reasonableness standard of review. It found that the first and second refusals were not identical because the later decision was made on a different evidentiary record and addressed a different regulatory provision, even though both decisions raised concerns about sufficient accessible funds.

Court accepts officer’s assessment of accessible funds

The applicant argued that the officer unreasonably repeated the earlier refusal reasoning and speculated about her father’s financial institution. She submitted that her father’s financial and professional profile, as well as his commitment to support her, showed that funds would be available.

The Court held that the applicant retained the burden of proving, on a balance of probabilities, that she met the applicable legal and regulatory requirements. It found that an officer was entitled to verify financial information rather than accept supporting documents without question.

Justice Duchesne noted that the officer considered the father’s funds to be held at a microfinance institution that was not easily verifiable. The Court also noted the officer’s finding that the applicant had not submitted further financial documents showing access to funds beyond those held by her father.

The Court found that the documents focused on the father’s means rather than demonstrating the applicant’s own financial means or easy access to her father’s funds. On the record before the officer, the Court concluded that declining to draw that inference was not unreasonable.

Practical Implications for Lawyers and RCICs

The Court’s finding was fact-specific: it accepted the officer’s concern about whether the proposed financial support would actually be accessible throughout the studies and for the applicant’s departure from Canada. The reasons stress that evidence of a sponsor’s resources did not necessarily establish the applicant’s access to those resources (paras 28–31).

For a comparable record, this suggests that a challenge to a study permit refusal based on financial evidence must address the officer’s actual analysis of the source, nature, stability and accessibility of the funds, rather than relying only on evidence that a relative has financial means.

Source: Federal Court Decisions

Disclaimer

Maplevisa provides Canadian immigration news and information for general informational purposes only. Content is not legal or immigration advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice based on your individual circumstances. Immigration laws, policies, programs, and procedures may change. Where applicable, readers should consult the relevant official government or legal source for current information.