The Federal Court set aside an open work permit refusal over financial evidence and the related temporary resident visa refusal for the applicant’s minor son. The Court found that the visa officer did not meaningfully address key evidence concerning the family’s finances, the spouse’s wages and her qualifying employment in Canada.

Case Summary
- Case & citation: Sond v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1397; Court file IMM-9664-25.
- Decision date & judge: November 13, 2026, by the Honourable Madam Justice Danielle Ferron.
- Issue: The Court reviewed refusals of an open work permit and a minor child’s temporary resident visa based largely on concerns about financial resources and temporary intent.
- Outcome: Judicial review was granted without costs; the applications were returned to a different officer for redetermination, with an opportunity for further submissions and evidence.
Why the Open Work Permit Refusal Over Financial Evidence Failed
Mr. Sond and his son had applied to join Mr. Sond’s spouse in Canada. The visa officer refused Mr. Sond’s open work permit application and the child’s temporary resident visa application on April 4, 2025, finding that they had not established they would leave Canada at the end of their authorized stay.
The applicants argued that the officer had not properly assessed evidence of Ms. Sond’s employment, wages and the family’s available funds. The Attorney General of Canada responded that the applicants bore the onus of showing they met the requirements and that the Court should not reweigh the evidence.
Justice Ferron applied the reasonableness standard. While recognizing that visa officers are owed considerable deference on discretionary, fact-based decisions, the Court held that the reasons still had to be justified, transparent and intelligible.
The Court noted that the officer’s reasons did not specifically refer to the low-income cutoff. It held that even if the officer had relied on that measure, this alone would not have been a reviewable error. The problem was the officer’s assessment of the record, not the mere use of a financial benchmark.
Court finds central evidence was not addressed
The GCMS notes referred to financial, property and gold documents, but did not acknowledge the savings in Mr. Sond’s bank accounts or explain whether those funds had been considered. The Court found it could not connect the officer’s conclusion that the applicants lacked sufficient resources to the evidence in the file (para 28).
The officer accepted that Ms. Sond worked as a retail supervisor earning a gross hourly wage of $21, but said the pay slips could not be associated with corresponding wages because bank statements were not provided. Justice Ferron found that the reasons did not explain why the employer’s letter and pay slips were enough to recognize her employment but insufficient to establish that she received wages from that employer (para 31).
The Court also found that the officer had not explained why documents concerning Ms. Sond’s position were insufficient to show qualifying training, education, experience and responsibilities category employment. The record included an employment letter identifying her role as NOC 62010 and TEER 2, a positive Labour Market Impact Assessment confirmation for that position, and her closed work permit (para 32).
The Court concluded that the refusals did not appear to be rationally based on the evidence filed. It allowed the judicial review and ordered a new determination by a different officer, rather than approving the open work permit or temporary resident visa applications.
Practical Implications for Lawyers and RCICs
The Court’s finding was fact-specific: it concerned reasons that did not address savings, pay slips, an employer letter and documents supporting the spouse’s TEER-qualified employment. For a comparable record, this suggests that where an officer treats missing bank statements as decisive, the reasons should explain why other direct wage and employment evidence was insufficient (paras 27–32). The judgment does not make bank statements unnecessary in every work permit application.
Source: Federal Court Decisions
Maplevisa provides Canadian immigration news and information for general informational purposes only. Content is not legal or immigration advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice based on your individual circumstances. Immigration laws, policies, programs, and procedures may change. Where applicable, readers should consult the relevant official government or legal source for current information.