A marriage genuineness assessment that led IRCC to refuse a Tanzanian applicant permanent residence has been set aside after the Federal Court found the officer relied on an unsupported assumption about how a spouse in a genuine marriage would respond to infidelity and bisexuality. The matter will be reconsidered by a different decision-maker.

Case Summary
- Case & citation: Kawishe v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1428; Court file IMM-10540-25.
- Decision date & judge: November 19, 2026, by Mr. Justice Norris.
- Issue: The Court reviewed an IRCC refusal of permanent residence based on the officer’s finding that the applicant’s marriage was not genuine.
- Outcome: Judicial review was allowed; the April 11, 2025 refusal was set aside and remitted to a different decision-maker for redetermination.
Marriage Genuineness Assessment and the Court’s Finding
The applicant was included as the spouse of a protected person on his permanent residence application. IRCC approved the permanent residence applications of her husband and their children, but refused hers after concluding that the marriage was not genuine.
The officer gave two principal reasons in the GCMS notes: the applicant’s reaction when questioned about her husband’s same-sex relationships, and the couple’s physical separation for more than six years, including two occasions when they did not meet while he was in neighbouring Kenya.
Justice Norris held that the assessment of the applicant’s reaction to her husband’s infidelity was unreasonable and determinative of the judicial review. The Court found that the officer effectively measured her response against an assumed standard of how a person in a genuine marriage should react.
The Court stressed that a person’s reaction to a partner’s infidelity or previously unknown sexual identity can be relevant to assessing a relationship. However, there is no single expected reaction, and the assessment must be grounded in the individual’s own circumstances.
In this case, the Court found no support in the record, logic or human experience for the apparent assumption that ending the marriage was the only reasonable response. That assumption did not provide a rational path from the applicant’s conduct to the conclusion that the marriage was not genuine.
Why the refusal was set aside
The parties agreed that the reasonableness standard applied. The Court concluded that the decision lacked the required transparency, intelligibility and justification in a key respect.
The Court did not need to decide the applicant’s other arguments, including her submission that the officer failed to engage with evidence supporting the marriage, such as its duration and the couple’s two children. The unreasonable assessment of her reaction to the disclosures was sufficient to require a new decision.
Practical Implications for Lawyers and RCICs
The Court’s finding was narrow but material: a relationship assessment cannot reasonably rest on an unsupported expectation that a spouse would respond to infidelity or sexual-identity disclosures in one particular way. For a comparable record, this suggests that the reasoning should connect the individual’s evidence and circumstances to the conclusion rather than rely on generalized assumptions about human behaviour.
The remedy was redetermination by a different decision-maker, not approval of permanent residence.
Source: Federal Court Decisions
Maplevisa provides Canadian immigration news and information for general informational purposes only. Content is not legal or immigration advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice based on your individual circumstances. Immigration laws, policies, programs, and procedures may change. Where applicable, readers should consult the relevant official government or legal source for current information.